If your ancestor won’t turn up on a New York passenger list, the problem is usually the index, not the ship. Arrivals from 1820 through 1891 (including the Castle Garden years) are in FamilySearch’s free New York passenger collection, and arrivals from 1892 through 1957 are in the free Ellis Island database. Search the name as it was spelled in the old country, loosen the spelling, use a census or naturalization record to narrow the year, and then read the manifest itself. And no, names were not changed at Ellis Island.
Which records cover which years
| Years | Where arrivals were processed | Where to search (free) |
|---|---|---|
| 1820 – 1855 | Customs lists; no central immigrant depot | FamilySearch: New York Passenger Lists, 1820–1891 |
| Aug. 1855 – spring 1890 | Castle Garden, the New York State immigrant depot | FamilySearch (same collection) |
| Spring 1890 – 1891 | Barge Office, a temporary federal depot | FamilySearch (same collection) |
| Jan. 1892 – June 1897 | Ellis Island | Statue of Liberty–Ellis Island Foundation; FamilySearch |
| June 1897 – Dec. 1900 | Barge Office again, after the Ellis Island fire | Same |
| Dec. 1900 – 1924 | Ellis Island | Same |
| 1925 – 1957 | Port of New York lists (inspection moved overseas in mid-1924) | Foundation; FamilySearch |
About CastleGarden.org: that website used to host Castle Garden searches, but it no longer loads, and FamilySearch now hosts the records. The Foundation’s database is at statueofliberty.org/arrival-search. FamilySearch’s collection is described here.
Step by step: how to find the ship
- Estimate the arrival year from records you already have. The 1900, 1910, 1920 and 1930 U.S. censuses each asked for year of immigration. Treat that year as a clue, not a fact: people misremembered it, so search at least three years either side. Naturalization papers filed after September 27, 1906 commonly list the ship, port and arrival date, so look for those first. (For New York census years, see our New York census guide.)
- Pick the right database for that year. Use the table above. If you’re unsure of the year, search all of the FamilySearch New York passenger collections. They’re free and cover 1820 through 1957.
- Search the name as it was spelled at home. Passenger lists were prepared at the port of departure, so the clerk wrote the home-country form. The Foundation’s own tips: Italian “Frank” is likely Francesco, German Franz, Polish Franciszek; “Joseph” is probably Giuseppe. Women, especially Italian women, often travel under their maiden surname. Also try the first name and surname reversed.
- Loosen the spelling. Use the database’s “sounds like,” “close match” and alternate-spelling options, or search a first initial plus a “contains” wildcard. Handwriting is often misread when records are indexed, so “Esposito” can become “Cspositio.” The old National Archives card index for 1902–1943 New York arrivals (T621) used Soundex, which groups surnames by consonant sound. Steve Morse’s free One-Step search form offers more flexible matching for 1892–1924.
- Stop searching your ancestor; search the people around them. Try a spouse, a sibling, a child with a simple first name, a travel companion, or the relative they were joining. The manifest names that relative from 1893 on. If you do know the ship, you can read that voyage’s pages line by line near the arrival date.
- Read the manifest image, not just the index. Check the village or last residence, the contact in the old country, and the destination address. Left-margin marks usually mean detention or a hearing before a Board of Special Inquiry, and details appear on a separate page at the end. Later notes in the margin often point to a naturalization number, which gives you your next record.
- Check other ports and spellings of the ship. Many immigrants landed at Boston, Philadelphia or Baltimore.
The “names were changed at Ellis Island” myth
Inspectors checked arriving passengers against a manifest the shipping company had already prepared overseas. They did not write or re-write names. The National Park Service says the same, and the Foundation notes that “immigrants were not given new names upon arrival.” Real spelling differences usually come from overseas clerks, a later indexing error, or the family choosing a new spelling after arriving, often when they naturalized. So search the original-language name, and keep an Americanized one as a backup.
A Brooklyn example (illustrative, not a real client)
Imagine a family in Bensonhurst looking for Carmine Esposito, born around 1888 in southern Italy. The 1930 census says he arrived in 1907, but the Ellis Island search for “Charles Esposito, 1907” finds nothing. Their 1915 naturalization petition, found through a county court index, lists a Naples departure and an arrival of October 1908. Searching the original-language name Carmine, with “sounds like” turned on and the year range set to 1906–1910, brings up a transcription as “Carmino Cspositio.” The manifest then shows his hometown and the brother he was joining in Brooklyn. Two documents, a year range and a different spelling: that is often all it takes.
Why this matters if you’re considering Italian citizenship
Families sometimes contact me wanting to pinpoint a specific Italian ancestor for citizenship by descent. The immigrant’s arrival record, birth record and naturalization date are central to those files. Note that Italian law changed in 2025: as of April 30, 2026, Italy’s Constitutional Court upheld rules under which a person born abroad who holds another citizenship generally qualifies only if a parent or grandparent held exclusively Italian citizenship (or a few narrow exceptions apply, or an application was filed by March 27, 2025). Whether you qualify is decided by an Italian consulate or court, not by a genealogist, so confirm with them or an Italian-law attorney. What I can do is document the paper trail. See our guide to New York records for Italian dual citizenship, our Italian genealogy guide and Italian surnames page.
When it’s worth hiring help
Get help when you’ve tried several spellings and a year range, the surname is common, the family used more than one name, or the lists are damaged or incomplete (for example, first- and second-class names are often missing from 1897 to about 1903). Help is also worth it when the arrival record is only the first step toward the village records overseas. I research families across the country, and New York records are my specialty. Send what you know, including the surname, rough dates and anything you’ve already searched, through the contact page. Not every ancestor can be found, and I’ll tell you honestly what I turn up and what I don’t. If you’re new to research, the beginner project is a good starting point.
Surname guides can help you guess at variant spellings: Italian, Irish, German and Polish.
Frequently asked questions
Is CastleGarden.org still online?
It no longer loads. FamilySearch now hosts the Castle Garden–era passenger lists for 1820–1891, free to search.
What years did Castle Garden and Ellis Island operate?
Castle Garden received immigrants from August 1855 to spring 1890. The Barge Office was a temporary depot until Ellis Island opened on January 1, 1892. After the June 1897 fire, the Barge Office was used again until December 1900.
Did Ellis Island officials change immigrants’ names?
No. Inspectors compared passengers to a manifest prepared at the port of departure. Spelling changes usually came from clerks overseas, indexing mistakes, or the family later.
What if I don’t know the ship or arrival year?
Look at the 1900–1930 censuses for a year of immigration and at naturalization papers filed after 1906 for a ship and date. Then search a year range, not one exact year.
Why can’t I find my ancestor even with the right spelling?
Common causes include misread handwriting in the index, a different first name, a woman traveling under her maiden surname, arrival at another port, or missing lists. Search relatives and companions, and browse the ship’s pages.
Can a passenger list prove Italian citizenship eligibility?
It documents an ancestor’s arrival, but eligibility depends on Italian law and the consulate’s review of birth, marriage and naturalization documents. Ask the consulate or an Italian-law attorney.